BARNS Logo
BARNS Logo
BARNS Logo
BARNS Logo
BARNS Logo
English
Glass bowl and view on skyline

Financial Reporting

Financial Reporting

Reporting, Processes & Governance

Reporting, Processes & Governance

Assurance

Assurance

Why Preparing for the Annual Audit Doesn't Start With the Auditor

Why Preparing for the Annual Audit Doesn't Start With the Auditor

Why Preparing for the Annual Audit Doesn't Start With the Auditor

Why good preparation for the annual audit doesn't start once fieldwork begins, but in the finance process itself.

Why good preparation for the annual audit doesn't start once fieldwork begins, but in the finance process itself.

Why good preparation for the annual audit doesn't start once fieldwork begins, but in the finance process itself.

Why Preparing for the Annual Audit Doesn't Start With the Auditor

Why good preparation for the annual audit doesn't start once fieldwork begins, but in the finance process itself.

The close gets done. The audit goes through. At the end, there's an unqualified opinion.

So the process was well set up?

Not necessarily.

Many companies get through year-end close and the audit every year, but only with real strain: countless follow-up questions, last-minute rework, knowledge that lives with individual people instead of being anchored in the process. Once the auditor arrives, things can get hectic, and by January the whole cycle often starts over again.

The obvious question at that point is usually: "Are we ready for the audit?"

The more interesting question is: "Is our close and reporting process set up, all year round, so that auditability is built in from the start?"

This is sometimes called audit readiness. What it means, in practice, is a close process organized so the audit doesn't turn into an annual scramble.

Good preparation for the annual audit usually isn't something you create three weeks before fieldwork begins. It tends to be the result of how finance works all year long.

At its core, this is about a shift: much of what counts as plausible in day-to-day operations has to be evidenced, traceably, for a third party during the audit. From "we know why we booked it that way" to "we can show why."

Where a lack of preparation shows up in practice

Some patterns tend to repeat across industries and company sizes:

  • Evidence and supporting documents get pulled together only once the auditor asks for them, rather than being organized as the year goes.

  • Accounting judgments, especially on complex or unusual matters, aren't documented, or not documented well enough. The reasoning exists, but only in one person's head.

  • Responsibilities and deadlines in the close process aren't clearly assigned; much of it runs on informal coordination.

  • Closing entries land late, sometimes only under the pressure of the upcoming audit.

  • Reconciliations and controls do happen, but aren't documented in a way anyone can trace. You know a review took place, just not how or by whom.

  • Data sits scattered across different spreadsheets and source systems with no single point of truth.

  • Process knowledge sits with a handful of key people. If one of them is out, the close stalls.

  • The same auditor questions come back year after year, with nothing carried forward into the next cycle.

  • Complex or unusual transactions get analyzed for their accounting treatment late in the process, once the room for judgment has already narrowed.

None of these points is dramatic on its own. Together, though, they can produce exactly the picture many finance teams know from experience: a close that feels like it has to be fought for, fresh, every single year.

What can be at stake when this preparation is missing

In the short term, this can show up mainly as extra effort: a longer audit, higher fees driven by follow-up questions, a later sign-off. Beyond that, it can keep having an effect:

  • Audit findings that may have to be explained to management, the advisory board, or shareholders.

  • Harder or delayed financing conversations, for instance when banks or investors, as part of a Schuldschein placement or a similar instrument, expect solid, audited figures by a fixed date.

  • A potentially weaker level of trust in the finance function, one that a better audit next year doesn't always restore right away.

That's often the real reason this kind of preparation is worth investing in: not for the sake of the audit itself, but for what can depend on it.

What good preparation actually means

Good preparation for the annual audit doesn't mean "more documentation for documentation's sake." It means treating auditability as a built-in part of the close process, not something bolted on afterward. In practice, that looks like:

  • Clear ownership and a closing calendar that everyone knows and actually follows.

  • Early identification of significant or complex accounting matters, ideally before the underlying transaction is already closed out.

  • Traceable accounting memos or position papers, wherever a matter's significance or complexity warrants one.

  • Reconciled accounts and solid evidence, built up over the year rather than assembled at the end.

  • Defined controls and documented reviews, not just performed, but visibly traceable.

  • Structured data storage, understandable without a specific person there to explain it.

  • Clear handoffs between accounting, controlling, tax, and other relevant functions.

  • Early alignment with the auditor on material issues, instead of raising them for the first time during fieldwork.

  • Lessons learned from last year's audit, actually carried into the next close instead of sitting unread in an email.

A better finance process, not an easier life for the auditor

Here's the key point: this isn't about making the auditor's job easier. That would be short-sighted, and frankly the wrong motivation.

It's about the fact that good preparation can primarily benefit your own finance function: less ad-hoc work, less dependence on individual people, fewer surprises right before close, faster turnaround, better traceability, including toward management, shareholders, or investors.

The financial statements are, and remain, management's and finance's responsibility. The auditor confirms that responsibility. They don't take it on.

Understood that way, preparing for the audit isn't a favor to the auditor, it's part of your own duty of care. That's the difference between a process that works toward the audit and a process that builds in auditability from the start.

Is the problem the audit, or the process before it?

When the same follow-up questions, rework, and reconciliation rounds show up year after year, the problem is rarely the audit itself.

It's usually the process that comes before it.

Does some of this sound familiar from your own company?

I support companies, through BARNS, in setting up their close and reporting processes so that auditability is built in from the start: Where do the same follow-up questions keep coming back? Where are responsibilities or documentation unclear? And where would a clearer closing calendar or earlier alignment with the auditor already make a real difference?

If you'd like to discuss your specific situation, feel free to get in touch.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual advice. The content reflects our assessment at the time of publication and makes no claim to completeness. For an assessment tailored to your company, please get in touch.

Getting the Numbers Right Is Not Enough: What Makes a Good Financial Close?

Getting the Numbers Right Is Not Enough: What Makes a Good Financial Close?

Getting the Numbers Right Is Not Enough: What Makes a Good Financial Close?

Are Your Reporting Processes Still Keeping Pace With Your Company?

Are Your Reporting Processes Still Keeping Pace With Your Company?

Are Your Reporting Processes Still Keeping Pace With Your Company?

Prefer to discuss your situation directly?

Prefer to discuss your situation directly?

BARNS Logo.

Advisory for financial and sustainability reporting.

© 2026 BARNS GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft. All rights reserved.

BARNS Logo.

Advisory for financial and sustainability reporting.

© 2026 BARNS GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft. All rights reserved.

BARNS Logo.

Advisory for financial and sustainability reporting.

© 2026 BARNS GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft. All rights reserved.

BARNS Logo.

Advisory for financial and sustainability reporting.

© 2026 BARNS GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft. All rights reserved.